I’m thinking I may have to create a category titled “The Older I Get” because the conversations in my head seem to be landing there a lot these days. For example, the older I get the more I ponder why we clap when we do and whether our choice of times to clap is appropriate.
This morning in church our pastor veered from his notes and made a Biblical statement about the sanctity of life. He was careful to point out that his statement was not political; rather, it was taken straight from the pages of God’s word. And it was. And I was so proud of him because not many pastors are brave enough to go there these days. It was refreshing. And I said, “amen!” along with several others.
And then someone started clapping – loudly. And suddenly I felt uncomfortable. I have no idea who started the clapping and, even if I did, I would not presume to make a judgement call on the heart motive of the clapper. It may have simply been their way of saying “amen!”
In the deep of me, this is what I thought. “Someone(s) here has been through the horror of abortion. Perhaps they have asked God to forgive them and they have been forgiven because that is what happens – even with abortion. And perhaps the sudden clapping in a place where there is generally no clapping during a sermon will bring a new level of condemnation for them. And if they feel condemned will they ever feel free to share their story? After all, their story could change some one else’s life and maybe even save the life of an unborn child. The shared story may even be a brand new place of freedom in their own life. So, should I clap along because I really am so thankful that FINALLY what breaks the heart of God is being spoken out loud or is my amen enough? Or is there even a difference between the two?”
So there is my question for today. To clap or not to clap?
Jo, your thoughtfulness leads me to a larger question — what is the line between standing up for what we believe and risking offending others? A big question for Christians these days and probably going to get bigger. I’ve been on both sides of the line — feeling the importance of standing up for beliefs, but other times seeing people I love hurt because someone else feels the need to speak out about their belief in a critical way. I’m not sure anything turns a person away from Christ more than that. I guess I think we have to take care to deliver our Christian beliefs in a way that shows love first, since Jesus said all the commandments rest on loving God and loving others. But it’s tricky to always know how to do that. Back to the clapping … I’m sure the person who started the clapping had the best intentions, but maybe it’s not a scenario where the love part can be communicated?
LikeLike
We had a conversation about this very thing last night because of something I have been wrestling with writing…for nearly a year. I think you are exactly right – love has to drive our intention. I’m afraid, as Christians, we have used love as an excuse to never confront as if one cancels the other out. It’s even in our pulpits; lots of feel good preaching with no confrontation. I wondered a time or two if I did not clap simply because I was so shocked to hear God’s word spoken publicly on a subject we never hear about outside of the liberal media. In those few seconds my brain just couldn’t process all I was thinking.
LikeLike
Good, thought provoking musing! It occurs to me that the applause in response to a comment in a sermon – not a “performance” in any sense of the word – was the individual’s way of “saying” AMEN. More than likely, someone who didn’t grow up in the church (as you and I) and was expressing affirmation of what was being heard.
LikeLike
And I love our “someones who didn’t grow up in the church!” I’m praying for more of them.
LikeLike
Hmm. I was there and I was a bit uncomfortable with the clapping but quickly sifted through reasons for clapping. I did not clap but I felt that people were agreeing with the pastor and not even thinking of those who may have had abortions. Love that God has given you a sensitive and tender heart, Jo.
LikeLike
I’m with you. We should not clap in that situation. Along with that, I played a very worshipful offertory this morning, Create in Me a Clean Heart and I did everything I could to keep the people from clapping, but someone started and they all clapped.
LikeLike
In theory, I am with you, JoAnne. But couldn’t a very loud and boisterous “amen” have the same effect also? I’m sure yours wasn’t that way, but I have heard people “amen” in a loud and judgmental way. Sort of in a self righteous manner. Just a thought. There, but for the grace of God, go I. (Love your thought-provoking posts.)
LikeLike
Enjoying your musings SO MUCH, dear Jo!
LikeLike